Demons don't deserve No.3 pick for Frawley, say Lions
End of first-round pick fairer compo for free agent Demon, say Lions.
Melbourne does not deserve pick No.3 as compensation for losing free agent James Frawley, Brisbane Lions chief executive Greg Swann says.
There has been plenty of conjecture about the Demons' compensation should Frawley officially leave the club when the free agency period opens on Friday.
A compensation selection immediately after the Demons' first-round pick, which is currently No.2, is one potential outcome but Swann believed that would be unfair on both his club and the rest of the AFL.
"We need to keep pick No.4," Swann told NAB AFL Trade Radio on Tuesday.
"Melbourne have done a really good job in trying to sell the world that they will get pick No.3 for James Frawley and that pushes us back to No. 5 and that has a little bit of an effect on our ability to trade as well.
"I know (Paul Roos) said that everyone he speaks to thinks that pick No.3 is a fair pick but we certainly don't. We would have thought an end of first round would be best for James."
Swann cited Hawthorn receiving pick No. 19 in last year's draft for losing Lance Franklin to the Sydney Swans as a relevant case study.
"We're talking pick No.3," Swann said.
"It's a massive pick in the draft and I would've thought that would be reserved for top-echelon players.
"We've got the immediate pick after so we go from four to five and that has a big effect on us and our ability to trade and everything else.
"It's an interesting debate. Certainly they need compensation, there's no doubt about that, but whether it's as high as pick No.3, obviously the panel that determines that will do so."
The Lions' No.4 selection has already been mooted as a key part of a possible trade with Collingwood for Dayne Beams.
Swann said that Lions' head of coaching and development, Peter Schwab, would sit down with Collingwood list manager Derek Hine at the NAB AFL Draft Combine in Melbourne this week to begin preliminary discussions regarding a trade for Beams.
Two-time Lions best and fairest Joel Patfull has indicated his willingness to move to a Sydney club and Swann said there was no animosity involved; rather, it was a polite request from Patfull with a view to his future.
"He's sort of looking at life post-footy and he thinks he'll end up in Sydney, as in Sydney the town, not Sydney the footy club." Swann said.
"He's got a year to run (on his contract) and he understands that we hold the aces there.
"But he's said in the end when he retires he'll end up in Sydney. If there's an opportunity to get there, he's happy to do it. If not, he's happy to stay.
"No one is killing themselves over it but it's just one of those ones that's been floated. So we'll have to work through that and see where that ends up."
Garner awarded captaincy, as three Roos make All-Australian team
North Melbourne Tasmanian Kangaroos trio Jasmine Garner, Ash Riddell and Alice O’Loughlin have been selected in the 2024 AFLW All-Australian team, with the former also named captain of the star-studded side
Skipper aces time trial as recruits, full squad return
Co-captain Jy Simpkin has set the standard as North Melbourne's five-year plus players returned for their first official day of the AFL pre-season
Gameday guide: Everything you need to know for Saturday's AFLW Grand Final
The North Melbourne Tasmanian Kangaroos will clash with Brisbane in the Grand Final for a second straight season
Grand Final bound: Tickets on sale for Saturday's decider
Everything you need to know about the big match and how to secure your tickets